Crypto, Blockchain and Digital Assets
Crypto and blockchain projects and transactions, token issuance, regulation and licensing in Israel, and work in the capital markets, payments and clearing.
The law office of Adv. Oren Chen advises entrepreneurs, companies and investors on projects and transactions in crypto, blockchain and digital assets, including: the legal structure of a project; token issuance; investment agreements; licensing requirements; and the tokenization of real estate assets.
Adv. Chen has represented local and international entities in the capital markets industries, including forex and digital currency trading, as well as in clearing and electronic accounting, digital marketing and e-commerce. A blockchain project is a business in every respect, with founders, investors, customers and contracts, except that some of the contracts are written in code and some of the regulation is still taking shape.
The regulatory framework in Israel
Israel has no single statute governing digital assets, and supervision is divided among several authorities and laws:
- Securities Law, 5728-1968: a token that confers rights similar to those of a security is subject to the Law when offered to the public in Israel, under the supervision of the Israel Securities Authority. The Law also governs the licensing of trading platforms, such as platforms for trading derivatives on foreign currency.
- Supervision of Financial Services (Regulated Financial Services) Law, 5776-2016: according to the position of the Capital Market, Insurance and Savings Authority, providing services to the public in virtual currencies requires a license to provide a service in a financial asset.
- Income Tax Ordinance: the Israel Tax Authority treats virtual currency as an asset and taxes the gain on its sale.
The field changes often, so each project is reviewed against the guidance in force at the time of the review.
Token issuance
The threshold question is which rights the token confers on its holder. A token that confers a share in profits, voting rights or a return on investment resembles a security, and offering it to the public in Israel requires compliance with securities law. A token used only to access a product or a service is assessed differently, but even then the distinction turns on the token’s features, not on what it is called. The answer determines the structure of the issuing entity, the documents for purchasers, the target audience and the country of the offering, and the taxation of the proceeds.
Investing in a blockchain project
In legal terms, an investment in a blockchain project is an investment in a business, even when it is made by purchasing a token. Before the funds are transferred, the review covers, among other things:
- The entity receiving the funds: where it is registered and who stands behind it.
- The consideration to the investor: tokens, shares, a future right to tokens or a combination of these, and the timetable.
- Restrictions on sale: lock-up periods, vesting and transfer restrictions.
- If the project does not go ahead: whether there is a right to a refund, and where the agreement provides for it.
- Tax and reporting: how the investment is taxed in Israel, and the reporting obligations.
Real estate tokenization
In Israel, ownership of land is determined by registration in the Land Registry, not on a blockchain. The asset is therefore usually held in a company or a trust, and the tokens represent a right in it. Such a structure raises several questions: whether the tokens are securities, what position the holders are in if the company runs into difficulty, and how the structure is taxed. The sale of rights in a company whose main assets are real estate may be treated as the sale of a right in a real estate association (igud mekarkein), which is subject to capital gains tax on real estate (mas shevach) and to purchase tax.
Payments, clearing and e-commerce
Crypto businesses operate alongside payment, clearing and digital marketing systems, and each of these has its own rules. The firm advises entities in these fields, including on agreements with payment and clearing providers, on digital marketing and affiliate agreements, and on activity that spans several jurisdictions.
The firm acts for projects and investors in this field alongside the client’s technology team and accountant. The work draws on the firm’s practice in corporate law, commercial agreements and real estate, which is where most of the legal work in digital asset projects lies.
Matters Handled
-
Legal structure for the project
Choice of entity and place of incorporation, and the allocation of rights among the founders, the investors and the community.
-
Token issuance
Whether the token may be considered a security, and what that means for offering it to the public.
-
Regulation and licensing
Whether a license is required from the Capital Market, Insurance and Savings Authority or from the Israel Securities Authority.
-
Agreements alongside smart contracts
A written agreement that sets out what applies when the code does not act as the parties intended.
-
Investment in digital assets
Review of the project and the issuing entity, the investment agreement and the rights granted to the investor.
-
Real estate tokenization
Holding structures through a company or a trust, and the gap between registration on a blockchain and registration in the Land Registry.
-
Capital markets and forex trading
Advising entities in foreign exchange and digital currency trading, and reviewing whether a license is required.
-
Payments, clearing and e-commerce
Agreements with payment and clearing providers, and digital marketing and affiliate agreements.
-
Tax aspects
Working with the client's accountant on the taxation of gains from digital assets and reporting to the Israel Tax Authority.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a token considered a security in Israel?
It depends on the rights the token confers. According to positions published by the Israel Securities Authority, a token that confers rights similar to those of a share or a bond, such as participation in profits, may be considered a security, and offering it to the public in Israel is subject to the Securities Law. A token used only to access a product or a service is assessed differently, and each case is assessed on its own features.
Is a license required for crypto activity in Israel?
According to the position of the Capital Market, Insurance and Savings Authority, providing services to the public in virtual currencies, such as trading, exchange or custody, is a service in a financial asset that requires a license under the Supervision of Financial Services (Regulated Financial Services) Law, 5776-2016. Activity that does not involve providing such a service to the public does not necessarily require a license, so the business model is reviewed before launch.
Is a license required for a forex trading platform?
Operating a trading platform, such as a platform for trading derivatives on foreign currency and contracts for difference (CFDs), requires a license from the Israel Securities Authority under the arrangement added to the Securities Law by Amendment 42. Operating a platform without a license is an offense, so the structure of the activity and the clients it targets are reviewed in advance.
How is the gain from selling virtual currency taxed?
The Israel Tax Authority treats virtual currency as an asset, not as currency. For an individual who does not carry on the activity as a business, the gain on a sale is generally taxed as a capital gain, at 25% of the real gain. Where the activity reaches the level of a business, the income is taxed at the rates that apply to business income.
Is a smart contract a binding contract?
A smart contract is code that performs actions automatically. Where an agreement between parties stands behind it, contract law applies to that agreement, and questions such as mistake, misrepresentation or a fault in the code are decided under the law. It is therefore advisable to attach a written agreement that sets out what applies when the code does not act as the parties intended.
What is real estate tokenization?
The division of the economic rights in a real estate asset into digital tokens, so that investors each hold a part of it. In Israel, ownership of land is determined by registration in the Land Registry, so the asset is usually held in a company or a trust, and the tokens represent a right in that company or trust. Such a structure may be considered an offering of securities, and it has real estate tax implications.
Contact
Meetings can be arranged by phone or email. All inquiries are kept confidential.
1 David Ben Gurion St., Bnei Brak
