Shareholders' Agreement: The Key Clauses Before an Investor Comes In
What a shareholders' agreement covers, how it differs from the articles, and what to settle before investment: control, transfers, dilution, vesting, exit.
Company formation and corporate structures in Israel and abroad, founders' and shareholders' agreements, investment rounds, mergers and acquisitions, restructuring and insolvency.
The law office of Adv. Oren Chen provides legal advice and counsel to companies, founders, shareholders and investors, from the formation of a company through its restructuring, sale or winding up. The firm acts for local and international corporations, and examines the corporate structure according to the client’s business, plans, risks and tax considerations. The firm’s work in this area includes, among other things: company formation and corporate structures in Israel and abroad; founders’, partnership and shareholders’ agreements; investment rounds and share allotments; mergers and acquisitions; restructuring; trusts; and insolvency and receivership proceedings.
The corporate structure follows from the planned activity: where the company will operate, who will hold it, how capital will be raised and what will be done with the profits. Where the business operates in several countries, the place of incorporation, the regulation in each country and international taxation are also examined. Under the Income Tax Ordinance, a company incorporated abroad whose business is controlled and managed from Israel may be considered an Israeli resident for tax purposes. The structure is therefore set before operations begin, together with the client’s accountant.
The firm also handles the establishment of trusts for holding shares and assets under the Trust Law, 5739-1979, and structures that combine companies in Israel and abroad.
The Companies Law, 5759-1999, and the company’s articles of association set the basic framework: the right to vote at the general meeting, the right to a dividend when one is distributed, and the right to inspect certain company documents. Where the company’s affairs are conducted in a manner oppressive to a shareholder, section 191 of the Law allows the shareholder to apply to the court.
The Law does not settle the practical questions that arise between shareholders: what happens when one of them stops working in the company, who approves an unusual expense or a loan, and whether shares may be sold to a third party and at what price. A shareholders’ agreement settles these questions in advance. A founders’ agreement, usually signed before the company has raised capital, sets out the division of shares and roles, share vesting, the assignment of intellectual property to the company and the arrangements when a founder leaves. Investors review both agreements in every round.
An investment in a company comes with terms: the price per share, additional rights for the investor, a board seat and sometimes a veto right. Before the term sheet is signed, the points examined include:
An offer of securities to the public requires a prospectus under the Securities Law, 5728-1968. A capital raise in a private company is therefore structured as a private placement, to a limited number of offerees or to investors listed in the First Schedule to the Law.
In the purchase or sale of a company, the first question is what is being transferred: the company’s shares, or its assets and business. This determines the scope of the due diligence, the representations and indemnities, the conditions to closing and the taxation of each party.
A restructuring of a group of companies, such as a merger, a split or a transfer of business between companies, is examined through several alternatives, since each has different consequences for creditors, for shareholders and for tax. When shareholders decide to part ways, an agreed arrangement is usually preferable to legal proceedings: it is faster and less costly, and it preserves the company’s value.
The Insolvency and Economic Rehabilitation Law, 5778-2018, which came into force in September 2019, governs the proceedings concerning a company that cannot pay its debts, its rehabilitation or liquidation, and the arrangements with its creditors. The firm advises companies and insolvency office holders in their dealings with creditors, represents parties in the proceedings, and handles the purchase and sale of assets in receivership proceedings.
The firm also advises directors and officers on the duty of care and the fiduciary duty that the Companies Law imposes on them, and on the exemption, indemnification and insurance arrangements that the Law permits.
The firm works with private companies, founders, shareholders and investors in Israel and abroad, alongside the company’s accountants on the tax aspects of allotments, investments and transactions.
Incorporation in Israel and abroad, articles of association and founding resolutions, set according to the business, its plans and the tax considerations.
Division of shares and roles, share vesting, assignment of intellectual property to the company and arrangements for a founder's departure.
Decision-making, appointment of directors, restrictions on share transfers and exit mechanisms.
Investment documents, investor rights, anti-dilution protection and structuring the raise to comply with securities law.
Purchase and sale of companies and businesses, from due diligence through closing.
Merger, split or reorganization of a group of companies, after several alternatives have been examined.
Dealings with creditors, representation in proceedings, and the purchase and sale of assets in receivership proceedings.
Advice and representation for directors and officers, including exemption, indemnification and insurance.
Trusts for holding shares and assets, in Israel and abroad.
The articles of association are the company's basic document and are filed with the Registrar of Companies. A shareholders' agreement governs the relationship among the shareholders themselves: decision-making, appointment of directors, share transfers, the entry of an investor and the ways to exit. Without an agreement, a dispute between shareholders will be decided under the articles and the Companies Law, and not necessarily as the parties intended.
Usually: the division of shares and roles, vesting of shares over a period of time, confidentiality and non-competition, assignment of intellectual property to the company, and arrangements for a founder who leaves or does not meet the obligations undertaken.
Dilution is a decrease in a shareholder's percentage holding when the company allots new shares, for example to an investor. It cannot always be prevented, but the agreement can provide for a preemptive right in new allotments, protection against an allotment at a lower price, and a veto right over material decisions.
An offer of securities to the public requires a prospectus under the Securities Law, 5728-1968. An offer to up to 35 offerees within a 12-month period, and to investors listed in the First Schedule to the Law, is not considered an offer to the public. Offerees are counted under rules set in the Law, so the structure of the raise is examined in advance.
Under the Income Tax Ordinance, a body of persons is an Israeli resident if it was incorporated in Israel, or if the control and management of its business are exercised from Israel. A company incorporated abroad but managed in practice from Israel may therefore be considered an Israeli resident and be liable to tax in Israel on its income.
Legal due diligence examines the capital and ownership structure, material contracts, liabilities and claims, employees, intellectual property and licenses. The findings affect the price and the representations and indemnities in the agreement, and sometimes the decision whether to acquire at all.
What a shareholders' agreement covers, how it differs from the articles, and what to settle before investment: control, transfers, dilution, vesting, exit.
Meetings can be arranged by phone or email. All inquiries are kept confidential.