BSR 2 Tower, 25th Floor, Bnei Brak

Shareholders' Agreement: The Key Clauses Before an Investor Comes In

Corporate Law Adv. Oren Chen 5 min read
A fountain pen on a writing pad
In short

A shareholders' agreement is a contract between the shareholders of a company that sets out how decisions are made, the restrictions on selling shares, the terms on which an investor comes in and the ways a partner can exit. It should be signed before an investor comes in: after the investment the founders' bargaining power is reduced, and any issue left open may turn into a dispute.

Many companies are formed by partners who trust one another, so a shareholders’ agreement is at first seen as a formality. Its importance becomes clear when something changes: an investor comes in, a partner wants to leave, or the shareholders disagree about the company’s direction. At that stage it is already harder to agree on its terms.

What is the difference between a shareholders’ agreement and the articles of association?

The articles of association are the company’s basic document under the Companies Law, 5759-1999. They are filed with the Registrar of Companies, and the Law provides that they have the effect of a contract between the company and its shareholders, and among the shareholders themselves. The articles also bind anyone who joins the company in the future.

A shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between the shareholders who sign it. It is not filed with the Registrar, it can be far more detailed, and it can also include personal undertakings, such as the division of roles, non-competition and provisions for a founder who stops working in the company.

Its drawback is that it binds only its parties. The main provisions, such as restrictions on share transfers and the majority required for material decisions, are therefore usually incorporated in the articles as well. That way they bind the company itself and anyone who joins it, and conflicts between the two documents are avoided. It is also common for the agreement to state which document prevails if a conflict between them emerges.

The key clauses in the agreement

ClauseWhat it sets out
Control and votingWho appoints directors, and which decisions require a qualified majority or the consent of all shareholders
Restrictions on share transfersWhether, and to whom, shares may be sold or transferred
Right of first refusalBefore a sale to a third party, the shares are offered to the other shareholders on the same terms
Tag-alongWhen a major shareholder sells, the minority may join the sale on the same terms
Drag-alongWhen a defined majority agrees to a sale of the company, the minority is required to sell as well
Anti-dilution protectionThe arrangement that applies to the investor if the company later raises capital at a lower valuation
VestingThe founders’ shares “vest” over time, and a founder who leaves early does not take all of them
DeadlockA mechanism for resolving a tie between the partners: escalation, mediation, arbitration or a buy-sell mechanism between them
ExitHow a partner exits, how that partner’s shares are valued, and who may buy them

Two clauses call for particular attention:

The list of material decisions. This sets out which decisions will not be made without broad consent, such as an allotment of new shares, the sale of a key asset, a change in the line of business, a dividend distribution or taking a significant loan. A minority shareholder without such protection is in practice dependent on the will of the majority.

Vesting of the founders’ shares. Without such a mechanism, a founder who leaves after one year keeps all of the founder’s shares, and the partners who continue to work hold a company a substantial part of which belongs to someone who no longer contributes to it. Investors almost always require such a mechanism, and it is preferable for the founders to agree its terms among themselves in advance.

What happens without a shareholders’ agreement?

In that case, the relationship between the partners is governed by the Companies Law and the articles of association. In many companies the articles are a standard form chosen at registration, with no restrictions on share transfers and no added protections for the minority.

This means that the majority at the general meeting decides most matters, and even the articles themselves can be amended by a resolution of the general meeting. A dispute often reaches the court, usually as an oppression claim under section 191 of the Companies Law. The court has broad discretion, and the remedies may go as far as separating the shareholders. However, this is a long and costly process, and its outcome is less predictable than that of a provision drafted in advance.

Settling the relationship between the founders before an investor comes in

An investor usually arrives with its own term sheet and investment agreement. Before that, the founders commonly settle among themselves:

  • Vesting and roles: the division of roles, and the arrangement that applies when a founder leaves, by agreement or otherwise.
  • Intellectual property: the development, the code, the brand and the know-how belong to the company, not to any individual founder.
  • An orderly cap table: who holds how much, and every commitment to allot shares or options to advisors and employees, in writing.
  • Employee option pool: if such a pool is needed, it is better to create it before the investment, since afterwards it dilutes the investor as well and becomes a point of negotiation.
  • Limits on the investor’s rights: which veto rights are acceptable to the founders, and which decisions remain with management.

There are several anti-dilution mechanisms. The more common one is based on a weighted average and adjusts the investor’s share price proportionally. A full-ratchet mechanism passes the entire difference to the investor, and can seriously harm the founders if the company has to raise capital at a low valuation.

When should the agreement be updated?

On any material change: an investment round, a new partner joining, a partner leaving, or a change in the division of roles. An agreement signed when the company was formed and not updated since usually reflects a different company from the one that exists today.

Summary

A shareholders’ agreement is not meant as preparation for a dispute, but as a way to settle in advance questions that every company reaches at some stage. The right time to put it in place is while relations between the partners are good and before an investor has entered the picture.

Adv. Oren Chen
Adv. Oren Chen

Heads a law office in commercial and business law, acting for companies, developers and investors in transactions and commercial disputes.

About

This article is general information only, correct as of its last update, and is not legal advice or a substitute for legal advice. Every case is assessed on its own facts.

More Articles

All articles