Dispute Between Partners: What to Do Before Going to Court
Disputes between business partners or shareholders in Israel: first steps, negotiation, mediation, arbitration or court, oppression claims, interim relief.
Representing companies, controlling shareholders and businesspeople in commercial and civil disputes, domestic and international, in the courts, in arbitration and in mediation.
The law office of Adv. Oren Chen represents Israeli and international companies, controlling shareholders, businesspeople, partnerships and ventures in commercial and civil disputes, domestic and international, and conducts settlement negotiations and mediation on their behalf. The firm appears in the Magistrates’ Courts, the District Courts and the Supreme Court, the Regional Labor Courts and the National Labor Court, and the Family Courts, as well as in arbitration and mediation. The disputes the firm handles include: disputes between shareholders and partners, including oppression claims; breach of contract claims; disputes in real estate transactions and commercial leases; monetary claims; and applications for interim relief.
The first weeks of a dispute often shape the rest of the proceedings. The course of action is set on the basis of an assessment of the prospects, the amount at stake and the cost of litigation, and before a letter is sent or the other party is approached, the following are examined:
Based on this review, the decision is made whether to open negotiations, send a demand letter or go to court.
The Contracts (Remedies for Breach of Contract) Law, 5731-1970, gives the party injured by a breach of contract the right to claim enforcement, to rescind the contract or to claim damages. A shareholder whose company’s affairs are conducted in a manner that oppresses that shareholder may apply to the court under section 191 of the Companies Law, 5759-1999, and the court may grant broad remedies, up to a full separation between the shareholders. Where the agreement provides for arbitration, the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968, governs the proceedings and the ways to confirm or set aside the arbitral award.
The Civil Procedure Regulations, 5779-2018, allow interim relief, such as an injunction or an attachment, to be sought at the very start of the proceedings, where there is a risk of damage that would be difficult to remedy.
| Court | Arbitration | Mediation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | A judge | An arbitrator chosen by the parties | The parties themselves, assisted by a mediator |
| Publicity | Public as a rule | Confidential | Confidential |
| Appeal | Right of appeal | Only if agreed in the arbitration agreement | No decision, so no appeal |
| Suited to cases where | A binding decision and remedies such as an injunction are needed | The agreement provides for arbitration, or experience in the field and confidentiality are needed | The parties have an interest in preserving the business relationship |
The choice between the proceedings also depends on what the parties agreed in advance. For this reason, the wording of the dispute resolution clause in the original agreement has a direct effect on how a dispute is conducted later. Adv. Chen also serves as an arbitrator.
In a dispute between parties from different countries, the law governing the agreement, the jurisdiction it sets and the arbitration clause, if there is one, are examined at the outset. At the same time, the question of where the other party’s assets are located is examined, since the ability to enforce the judgment in practice depends on it. A foreign judgment is enforced in Israel under the Foreign Judgments Enforcement Law, 5718-1958, and Israel is a party to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards. The firm advises entities from abroad in English, and works alongside local counsel when part of the proceedings takes place outside Israel.
At the start of the proceedings, the prospects of the claim, the amount at stake and the expected cost of each stage are assessed: pleadings, document disclosure, expert opinions and evidentiary hearings. The assessment makes it possible to decide in advance how far the proceedings will go, and at what point a settlement will be considered. At the end of the proceedings, the court may order the losing party to pay legal costs, and in that decision it also considers the conduct of the parties during the proceedings.
The firm represents clients both as plaintiffs and as defendants. The representation draws on close familiarity with the transactions, contracts and company law from which many commercial disputes arise.
Oppression claims, deadlock in the management of the company, and separation between partners.
Claims for enforcement, rescission and damages, and defense against such claims.
Filing monetary claims between businesses and in civil matters, and defending against claims filed against the client.
Disputes between parties from different countries, advice in English to entities from abroad, and enforcement of judgments and arbitral awards.
Representation in arbitration proceedings, and applications to confirm or set aside an arbitral award.
Applications for injunctions and temporary attachments, and defense against such applications.
Disputes in sale transactions, combination deals and commercial leases.
Representation in the Regional Labor Courts and the National Labor Court, and in property disputes in the Family Court.
Conducting settlement negotiations and mediation, alongside the legal proceedings or in place of them.
First, the documents are reviewed: the partnership agreement or shareholders' agreement, the articles of association and the correspondence between the parties. Sometimes a well-drafted demand letter or mediation brings the dispute to an end. Where that is not enough, the choice is between arbitration, if the agreement provides for it, and a claim in court.
Arbitration is a private proceeding that the parties agree to, usually in advance in the agreement. It is confidential, sometimes faster, and the parties can choose an arbitrator with experience in the field. Court proceedings are public, and the rights of appeal are broader. An arbitral award can be appealed only if the parties so provided in the arbitration agreement; in addition, the law sets narrow grounds for setting the award aside.
A claim by a shareholder under section 191 of the Companies Law, where the affairs of the company are conducted in a manner that oppresses that shareholder. The court may grant a wide range of remedies, from a specific order on the management of the company to requiring the other shareholders or the company to buy the shareholder's shares.
The court examines whether prima facie evidence of the claimed right has been presented, and whether, without the order, damage will be caused that would be difficult to remedy by the end of the proceedings. The balance of convenience between the parties and the good faith of the applicant are also weighed. For this reason, an application for interim relief is filed early and is well supported.
Yes. The firm represents and advises companies and entities in Israel and abroad, in Hebrew and English. In a dispute between parties from different countries, the governing law and the jurisdiction set in the agreement are examined, as is the possibility of enforcing the judgment or the arbitral award in the country where the other party's assets are located.
The length of the proceedings depends on the complexity of the case, the court and its caseload. Complex commercial claims may take a long time, so from the start of the proceedings, ways to end the dispute earlier, such as mediation or settlement, are also considered.
Disputes between business partners or shareholders in Israel: first steps, negotiation, mediation, arbitration or court, oppression claims, interim relief.
Meetings can be arranged by phone or email. All inquiries are kept confidential.