BSR 2 Tower, 25th Floor, Bnei Brak

Dispute Between Partners: What to Do Before Going to Court

Commercial Litigation Adv. Oren Chen 5 min read
An empty company boardroom
In short

Before going to court, the documents should be gathered, the provisions of the founders' agreement or shareholders' agreement and the articles of association reviewed, and negotiation or mediation considered. Where the agreement contains an arbitration clause, the dispute will usually be heard in arbitration rather than in court. A shareholder oppressed by the way the company's affairs are conducted may file an oppression claim, and where there is an immediate risk to assets, interim relief can be sought.

A dispute between business partners, or between shareholders in a private company, usually concerns three matters: money, control and exit routes. The steps taken in the first weeks often shape the rest of the dispute, even before a claim is filed.

First steps

At the outset, it is important to avoid hasty action and to gather the full picture:

  • The founders’ agreement or the shareholders’ agreement, and any amendment signed to it.
  • The company’s articles of association, and the company’s details at the Registrar of Companies: who the shareholders, the directors and the authorized signatories are.
  • Minutes of board meetings and general meetings, financial statements and bank statements.
  • Relevant correspondence: email, messages, and oral agreements that can be proven.
  • A short timeline of events.

The founders’ agreement, the shareholders’ agreement and the articles

In many cases the agreement between the parties already determines how the dispute will be resolved. The points examined include:

  • Dispute resolution clause: whether mediation or arbitration is required before going to court.
  • Exit mechanisms: a right of first refusal, a tag-along right and a BMBY (Buy Me Buy You) mechanism, in which one partner names a price and the other chooses whether to buy or to sell.
  • Deadlock resolution: what happens when the board or the shareholders cannot reach a decision.
  • Appointment rights: who appoints the directors and who actually manages the company.

In a partnership that is not a company, the relationship between the partners is governed by the partnership agreement and the Partnerships Ordinance [New Version], 5735-1975.

Ways to resolve a dispute between partners

Direct negotiation. The fastest and least costly route, as long as the parties are still in contact. Conducting the negotiation through lawyers helps prevent escalation.

Mediation. A neutral mediator helps the parties reach an agreement, but does not decide the dispute. The process is confidential, and it allows arrangements that a court cannot order, such as a gradual separation on an agreed timetable. Under section 79C of the Courts Law, the court may refer a matter to mediation, and a mediation agreement can be given the effect of a judgment.

Arbitration. An arbitrator chosen by the parties decides the dispute, in a private process that is usually faster than proceedings in court. Under the Arbitration Law, 5728-1968, an arbitration agreement must be in writing. Where the agreement contains an arbitration clause and one party nevertheless files a claim in court, the other party may apply for a stay of proceedings (section 5). An arbitral award is, as a rule, final: it can be set aside only on the narrow grounds set out in the Law, and an appeal is possible only if the parties agreed to it in advance.

Court. A public and formal process, with a right of appeal, and usually the longest and most costly of the alternatives.

RouteWho decidesPrivate or publicEstimated durationRelative costAppeal
NegotiationThe partiesPrivateDays to weeksLowNot applicable
MediationThe parties, assisted by a mediatorConfidentialWeeks to monthsLow to mediumNo decision, only an agreement
ArbitrationAn arbitrator chosen by the partiesPrivateMonths, sometimes longerMedium to highLimited, only if agreed
CourtA judgePublic, as a ruleUsually yearsHighRight of appeal

The durations and costs in the table are a general estimate only. In practice they depend on the complexity of the dispute, the amounts involved and the conduct of the parties.

What is an oppression claim?

Section 191 of the Companies Law, 5759-1999, allows a shareholder to apply to the court where the company’s affairs are conducted in a manner oppressive to that shareholder. The court may give directions to remove or prevent the oppression, for example directions on the future management of the company, or an order that the other shareholders or the company purchase the shareholder’s shares.

Oppression claims are particularly common in private companies, where the majority shareholders shut out the minority: removing it from management, withholding information from it, diluting its holdings or rewarding themselves in ways that bypass it. The court has broad discretion in choosing the remedy, so the way the claim is built from the outset carries considerable weight.

Where the harm is caused to the company itself, for example where a manager diverts business to a private company that the manager owns, the usual route is a derivative claim on behalf of the company. The Supreme Court has held that in certain cases, where the harm to the company is connected to the oppression of the shareholder, relief may also be granted within the oppression claim itself.

Valuing each partner’s share

In many disputes between partners, the main disagreement is not over the separation itself but over the price. Even when both sides agree to part ways, negotiations often stall on the valuation.

The first step is to check whether the agreement provides a valuation mechanism, such as an agreed appraiser or a formula. Without such a mechanism, the parties can agree on an independent appraiser and decide in advance that the valuation will bind both of them. A professional, agreed valuation narrows the dispute, and it is often what allows the dispute to be resolved in mediation rather than in court.

When is interim relief sought?

Where there is an immediate risk, there is no point in waiting for the end of the proceedings. Such situations include, for example, transferring assets out of the company, emptying bank accounts, convening a meeting intended to dilute a partner, or selling a key asset. In these cases the court can be asked for a temporary injunction, a mandatory order or a temporary attachment.

Under the Civil Procedure Regulations, 5779-2018, the court examines, among other things, whether there is prima facie evidence of the right, the balance of convenience between the harm to each party, the applicant’s good faith and the proportionality of the relief. Timing carries weight: an applicant who waited a long time before filing may face the argument that the urgency is not genuine. Even when the dispute is being heard in arbitration, the court can, in appropriate cases, be approached for relief in aid of the arbitration.

Actions to avoid

  • Withdrawing funds from the company, changing the authorized signatories, or blocking the other partner’s access to accounts and systems.
  • Convening meetings or passing resolutions other than in accordance with the procedures in the articles and the Law.
  • Setting up a competing business, or taking clients and documents, before matters have been settled.
  • Sending threatening messages on WhatsApp or by email; any message may be used as evidence.
  • Publicizing the dispute on social media.
  • Ignoring the arbitration clause or the deadlines set in the agreement.
  • Delaying: the longer the dispute continues, the harder it is to preserve the company’s value.

A dispute between partners does not necessarily end in court. When it is examined at an early stage and on the basis of the documents, it can often be resolved by agreement, in mediation or in arbitration, without prolonged litigation.

Adv. Oren Chen
Adv. Oren Chen

Heads a law office in commercial and business law, acting for companies, developers and investors in transactions and commercial disputes.

About

This article is general information only, correct as of its last update, and is not legal advice or a substitute for legal advice. Every case is assessed on its own facts.

More Articles

All articles